What Doctors Get Wrong About STI Testing

And Why It Matters More Than People Realize

This might sound bold, but the evidence is overwhelming. Unless a physician has personally taken the time to study sexually transmitted infection screening, they are very unlikely to test someone correctly. Not because they are careless. Not because they do not care. Simply because the system they work in makes it almost impossible.

Let me show you what I mean.

One large study reviewed forty five million gonorrhea and chlamydia tests in the United States. Out of all those tests, only one percent of women were ever given a throat swab, even though oral gonorrhea is more common than genital gonorrhea in women. Genital only testing misses most cases. Yet only a tiny minority of physicians perform oral or anal swabs unless a patient specifically asks for them. And even when a patient does ask, many physicians either do not know how to perform the testing correctly or will decline to do it altogether.

So let us look at why this happens.

⸻

Physicians Are Expected to Know Everything, Which Means They Cannot Specialize in This

Think about the typical physician’s day.

The first patient may need a referral to an oncologist because the doctor suspects cancer.

The next might have a sprained ankle.

The one after that has vague abdominal pain.

Then someone comes in with chronic back pain.

Then someone’s blood pressure crashes and an ambulance needs to be called.

And then you walk in and say you want to be tested “for everything.”

That is not a simple request.

That is essentially asking someone who treats the entire human condition to suddenly perform the job of a sexual health specialist.

Now compare that to a specific problem like:

“It hurts when I pee and there is green discharge.”

Doctors are trained for that. That is problem solving. That is familiar. That is straightforward.

But proactively testing someone for all major STIs across every relevant anatomical site. That is not something most physicians have ever been taught to do.

⸻

Electronic Health Record Systems Make It Worse

Doctors use electronic health record systems to order labs. These systems do not contain a button labeled Full STI Panel.

So when you ask to be tested for everything, the physician must:

• remember every STI
• find each one inside the menu system
• choose the correct specimen type
• decide which anatomical sites to swab
• order each test individually

It is a process no human could reliably execute in a rushed clinical environment. And the data proves they do not.

⸻

Federal Guidance Is Outdated And Often Misleading

Most people do not realize that preventive screening guidelines in the United States are created by the United States Preventive Services Task Force, a group of sixteen volunteers who meet three times per year and decide what preventive care should look like nationally.

Their STI screening recommendations are not what most people assume.

For example:

They state there is insufficient evidence to recommend gonorrhea screening for men who have sex with women.

They recommend syphilis screening primarily for men who have sex with men, African Americans, or individuals recently released from prison.

If a physician follows federal guidance, they likely will not test you at all unless you are symptomatic or fall into a narrow risk category.

This is not a critique of physicians. It is a critique of the structure they operate in.

⸻

Non-Reportable STIs Are Often Completely Overlooked

Doctors know that some STIs must be reported to public health officials: HIV, syphilis, gonorrhea, and chlamydia.

But important infections such as Mycoplasma genitalium and Trichomonas are not reportable. They are common, clinically relevant, and often silent, but because they are not mandated for reporting, they slip out of mind.

If something is not required, it is not prioritized.

⸻

The Real Problem Is Systemic, Not Personal

When you look at all of this together, the issue becomes obvious.

Doctors are responsible for everything from cancer to colds to cardiac emergencies. They have minimal specialized training in sexual health. Their computer systems work against them. Federal guidance is outdated. And essential infections are not on any mandatory reporting list.

The real question is not why most physicians struggle with comprehensive STI testing.

The real question is how any physician manages to excel at it at all.

Yet some do. Some clinicians spend their own time learning this field, staying current on the science, and understanding the importance of multi-site testing. Those clinicians deserve enormous respect.

⸻

But For Sexually Active, Sex-Positive People… The Traditional System Often Falls Short

Being a physician is one of the hardest jobs on earth. We have a team of physicians at ShamelessCare.com, and they work tirelessly to help patients every day.

But for people who are proactive, sexually active, and want thorough, site-specific testing, the traditional medical system simply is not designed to meet their needs.

If you want accurate STI testing that reflects real sexual behavior across all relevant anatomical sites, the evidence shows you probably will not get that from your local physician.

And that is exactly why Shameless Care exists.